Mattress firmness quiz

Three questions, and the arithmetic behind the answer shown in full.

Firmness is what buyers get wrong most often, and the reason is that a rating describes how a mattress responds to a standard load. You are not a standard load.

How do you mostly sleep?
Roughly what do you weigh?

Firmness ratings are calibrated for about 10 to 15 stone, so this shifts the answer.

Do you wake with pain?

How the answer is worked out

No black box. The quiz applies three adjustments in order.

The scale, 1 softest to 10 firmest12345678910Side4 to 6Back6 to 8Front7 to 9Combination6 to 7Then weightstartunder 11 stone,one step softerover 16 stone,one step firmerRatings are calibrated for roughly 10 to 15 stone, so outside that bandthe number means something different.
The scale, 1 softest to 10 firmest12345678910Side4 to 6Back6 to 8Front7 to 9Combination6 to 7Then weightstartone step softer under 11 stone,one step firmer over 16Ratings are calibrated for roughly10 to 15 stone, so outside that bandthe number means something else.
The whole of the arithmetic, in one place. Your sleeping position sets the starting range, and your weight moves it one step, because a firmness rating describes how a mattress answers a standard load and you are not a standard load. The output is a shortlist filter rather than a specification: nobody measures firmness to a standard, so one brand’s 7 is another’s 6, and the trial is what settles it.
Starting range by position
You sleepStart atBecause
Side4 to 6Shoulder and hip must sink for the spine to stay straight
Back6 to 8The lumbar hollow needs filling without the hips dropping
Front7 to 9The hips must be held up or the lower back over-extends
Combination6 to 7A middle rating beats optimising for one position

Then weight. One step softer under about 11 stone, one step firmer over about 16. Firmness ratings are calibrated for roughly 10 to 15 stone, so outside that band the number means something different.

Then symptoms. Lower back ache on waking that eases as you move usually means too soft. Hip or shoulder pain when side sleeping usually means too firm.

What this cannot tell you

There is no industry standard behind the firmness scale. Each manufacturer sets its own numbers, so a 7 from one brand is not necessarily a 7 from another. The range is a shortlist filter, not a specification.

Firmness is not support. Firmness is how the surface feels immediately; support is whether your spine stays in a reasonable position all night. A firm mattress with few springs is firm by barely compressing, which is not the same thing.

Your base changes the answer. A platform top divan firms a mattress; sprung slats soften it. The same mattress on two bases is two different beds.

Two people need two answers. If you share with someone much heavier or lighter, one surface cannot be right for both, and dual firmness or zip and link is the structural fix. It works properly from king width upward, because you need to be clear of the transition zone down the middle.

What to do with the number

Use it to shortlist, then buy with a trial. A comfort exchange beats a refund, because it lets you correct the firmness rather than start the search again.

Give it a fortnight. A new mattress feels different from the one you have adapted to, and your body takes that long to recalibrate. This is why trials have minimum periods of around 21 to 30 nights.

Ask for the construction too, either spring count in your size or foam density, because a firmness number without either tells you very little about how long it will last.

How this site works

Nothing here is paid for by a brand. No manufacturer has copy approval, a preview, or the ability to change a score, and where a link earns a commission that never changes a ranking.

Where a brand does not publish a specification, that is stated rather than estimated, because an absent number is itself information. The corrections log and the products I will not recommend page are both public.